Critiques: The website's front page video is difficult to comprehend over loud music. The connection between the video and the guild's purpose is unclear.
Activity on social media is lacking:
- Discord is well-structured yet needs urgent participation and a moderator.
- Twitch is completely empty, with no posted videos or scheduled events.
- Twitter only has 1.8k followers, which is low traction.
The Launcher website looks incomplete, with many "Coming Soon" elements, raising concerns around abandonment, lack of resources, team capabilities, and hype. I failed multiple times to download the launcher.
Positives: -The game selection is good for guilds. Monetizable.
- Despite being recently formed, the " Developer Diaries" articles demonstrate initiative.
- The Amber League roles provide progression paths and governance.
Conclusion: The project exhibits strategic promise in some areas but it critically lacks awareness, activity, and delivery in its current form. Significant improvements in marketing, community-building, and product rollout appear to be urgently needed to make this a compelling investment at this stage. Show Less
2
