Worldcoin offers a Faustian bargain - give up biometric data from iris scans in exchange for potential crypto rewards. But can we trust their assurances of privacy? Supposedly zero-knowledge proofs prevent misuse of data. However, there hasn't been confirmed yet.
Founded by Sam Altman, Worldcoin want to establish Proof-of-Personhood via iris-scanning orbs and implement somehow a way to distribute Universal Basic Income (UBI) worldwide. Over 150 developers have joined and shared Altman's vision of borderless financial inclusion.
These are the 2 more severe controversies to be concerned about:
-
Privacy - Worldcoin claims zero-knowledge proofs protect sensitive data. Yet there isn't true confirmation of that. Worldcoin claims it will keep this data secure, but are they sure of it?
-
Sustainability - Where does Worldcoin's capital come from to fund massive weekly airdrops? Their economics stay opaque.
Currently, we depend on government-approved documentation for identity proof, and probably a lot of people want a decentralized way that isn't limited by governments, politics, or borders. Seems that Worldcoin has put itself as the one who has the solution, but is this sufficiently decentralized?
I feel just a handful of powerful people have claimed authority over an immense amount of sensitive data. True decentralization requires open-source systems without centralized points of control. But so far, the structure seems to lack the openness expected of a decentralized ecosystem.
A tweet from @ZachBT shows us once more how controversial is this project. Check it out: https://shorturl.at/dyP34
I signed up because I was curious and I thought was cool, right? Then it comes the part where I have to go in person to Seoul, to a physical location to scan my iris, and I started thinking and wondering. What is it for me? What do I get in exchange for this?
Then, Immediate benefits:
- airdrop estimated at $200 over time, that if you are an early sign-up. ( I understand that in some places this is a huge financial impact, but where I live that's not the case).
Potential future benefits AS/IF the project moves forward.
- the opportunity to earn additional WLD tokens through mining, if mining (?)
- access to financial services built on Worldcoin's platform
- support and contribute to the development of a new decentralized global digital currency ecosystem (indirect benefit)
- if the project succeeds, a share from UBI through cryptocurrency (no realistic)
They're making big claims about rewards without showing us enough evidence that it can really happen. As a new, dreamy, and unproven concept, the potential rewards come loaded with uncertainty.
Worldcoin's vision is trailblazing but still speculative, and the project's success is far from certain. Show Less